Using Weather Derivatives to Mitigate Weather-Related Risk in a Changing Climate

Weather derivatives are financial instruments designed to manage or hedge against weather-related risks. They provide a means for organizations and individuals to protect themselves from financial losses resulting from adverse weather conditions. For example, an agricultural company heavily reliant on specific weather conditions for crop production can use weather derivatives to protect itself from losses due to unfavorable weather. By purchasing weather derivatives tied to rainfall levels or temperature thresholds, the company can receive compensation if the weather conditions deviate significantly from the expected norms. This compensation can help offset financial losses incurred from crop damage or reduced yields.

Weather derivatives work by creating a contract between two parties, where one party agrees to pay the other based on the occurrence or deviation of a specific weather parameter from a predetermined baseline. For example, a ski resort might purchase a weather derivative contract that pays out if the average temperature during the winter season exceeds a certain threshold. If the winter turns out to be unusually warm, leading to reduced snowfall and fewer visitors to the resort, the ski resort can receive a payment from the weather derivative contract to offset their decreased revenue.

Weather derivatives can be traded either over-the-counter (OTC) or on organized exchanges. In OTC trading, parties engage in direct negotiations and customization of contracts to suit their specific needs and risk exposures. This flexibility allows for greater customization but necessitates finding direct counterparties willing to assume the associated risk. OTC weather derivatives encompass a broad range of options tied to specific weather variables, such as temperature, wind speed, rainfall, and snowfall. On the other hand, organized exchanges provide standardized weather contracts that are readily accessible to a wider range of participants. These exchanges offer centralized platforms where buyers and sellers can engage in trading standardized weather derivative contracts, thereby enhancing market liquidity and transparency.

Weather derivatives can assume various forms, such as futures, options, and weather swaps

Some well-known weather exchanges include the Chicago Mercantile Exchange (CME) and the Intercontinental Exchange (ICE). For example, CME offers weather futures and options linked to three weather indices: CDD, HDD, and CAT.

Cooling Degree Days (CDD) are a way to quantify the amount of cooling required in a specific location during a certain period. CDD is calculated as follows:

CDD = Max (0, daily average temperature – 65°F or 18°C)

Higher CDD values indicate warmer weather and increased demand for air conditioning or cooling. The derivative contracts for the US cooling season, which refers to the summer months, are based on CDD.

Heating Degree Days (HDD) are used to estimate the amount of heating required in a specific location during a certain period. HDD is calculated as follows: HDD = Max (0, 65°F or 18°C – daily average temperature). Higher HDD values indicate colder weather and increased demand for heating. The derivative contracts for the US heating season, which refers to the winter months, are based on HDD. 

Cumulative Average Temperature (CAT) represents the sum of daily average temperatures throughout a calendar month.  CAT is used for Tokyo contracts and European cooling season contracts.

Take a utility company, for example. During a heating season, if the temperature is higher than anticipated, the demand for electricity for heating purposes will decrease, adversely affecting the company’s revenue. To mitigate this risk, the company requires a hedging tool that will increase in value as the temperature increases (i.e., as the HDD decreases). A short position in HDD futures will serve precisely that purpose. Conversely, short-selling CDD futures can protect the company from reduced electricity demand during mild summers.

Weather derivatives share similarities with insurance but also have distinct differences. Insurance primarily focuses on providing coverage for significant losses or events that may have a substantial impact on the insured party. It aims to protect against unexpected and catastrophic events. On the other hand, weather derivatives, such as temperature or precipitation contracts, provide a flexible tool for managing various types of risks. They provide a means to manage the financial impact of smaller-scale weather variations, allowing businesses to mitigate risks associated with regular weather patterns that may affect their operations or revenue.

Trading weather derivatives involves understanding the underlying weather indices and their historical patterns, as well as assessing the potential impacts of weather on specific industries or businesses. Data from weather monitoring stations, meteorological agencies, and other sources play a crucial role in determining the payout or settlement of weather derivative contracts.

It’s important to note that weather derivatives are primarily used by businesses and industries exposed to weather-related risks, such as agriculture, energy, retail, tourism, and insurance sectors. However, there are also financial institutions and specialized weather risk management firms that actively participate in weather derivative markets.

As with any financial market, participants in weather derivative trading should conduct proper due diligence, seek professional advice, and carefully assess their risk tolerance and hedging strategies before engaging in weather derivatives transactions.

Like (0)